Rob Roy vs Braveheart

[Cambo71]

I just watched Rob Roy and Braveheart yesterday which one is better?

Lets do a comparison.

Lead Actor Liam Nissan vs Mel Gibson - Winner Braveheart

Lead Actress Jessica Lange vs some chick - Winner Rob Roy (lange is a milf)

Old Bad guy John Hurt vs Patrick Mcgoohan - Winner Braveheart Mcgoohan is great

Young Nemisis Tim Roth vs Some Guy with Bad Teeth - Winner Rob Roy Roth is just great

Better Action Scenes - Winner Braveheart

Better Love Story - Winner Rob Roy

Ending More Likely To Make You Cry - Winnner Braveheart

Better over all movie - Winner Rob Roy

[DevilFish73]

Braveheart w/o question........

[ImADonk]

ummm.... really?

Braveheart:
Lead Actor - Winner Braveheart
Old Bad guy -Winner Braveheart
Better Action Scenes - Winner Braveheart
Ending More Likely To Make You Cry - Winnner Braveheart

vs.

Rob Roy:
Lead Actress - Winner Rob Roy
Young Nemisis - Winner Rob Roy
Better Love Story - Winner Rob Roy

[Cambo71]

Originally Posted by ImADonk

ummm.... really?

Braveheart:
Lead Actor - Winner Braveheart
Old Bad guy -Winner Braveheart
Better Action Scenes - Winner Braveheart
Ending More Likely To Make You Cry - Winnner Braveheart

vs.

Rob Roy:
Lead Actress - Winner Rob Roy
Young Nemisis - Winner Rob Roy
Better Love Story - Winner Rob Roy

Well I like Rob Roy a little better, both great movies. Anyways I started the thread so I get to choose.

[ImADonk]

Originally Posted by Cambo71

Well I like Rob Roy a little better, both great movies. Anyways I started the thread so I get to choose.

And that is absolutely your prerogative. I just think your reasoning is a little off. You came up with 7 categories to rate the films in which 4 go to Braveheart while 3 to Rob Roy. Based on that alone the pick should be Braveheart. In addition, the two MOST important criteria (lead actor and best action scenes) you have going to Braveheart. Again, your picks point towards Braveheart, not Rob Roy