Special place for our best threads

Everyone seems to really like this idea, so I've moved it into it's own thread in the public area. :)

Next we need to figure out the best way to actually implement this concept. Here are some of the ways I can think of.

1. We could create a completely new forum category called 'Best of BadBeatsPoker', and MOVE all these threads there. The down side to this is that the threads will no longer be located in the place where one would expect to look for them. For example, our best SNG strategy thread could no longer be found in the SNG Strategy category.

2. We could create a completely new forum category called 'Best of BadBeatsPoker', and COPY all these threads there. The down side to this is that the threads would now be duplicated, and any new posts to one of the two threads would only appear in one of the two locations.

3. We could simply 'sticky' each 'Best Of' thread, so that it always appears at the top of it's respective forum category. This approach seems the most logical to me right now.

What do you all think?

I saw we move all the threads to a new forum, lock the thread so noone can reply, and the last post will be a redirect link to where they can reply.

The purpose is so we can give a single URL to show a prospective user the best of the best. This is why I don't think sticky aligns with this goal.

To the top...

I think the guy who started the Beating 45's thread is brilliant, and should be paid royalties.

i agree with this thread 100% i think it is a great idea as well.. being somewhat new to the site i know my way around a little now but this is a great idea for the site.. this will help the newbies who are looking for information greatly..
I dont know if this was already said or not i didnt read thru every response but maybe if possible create a section labeled best of forum other than sum links to find it.. that way all these great discussions and threads will be just labeled in there own field...
Like i said dont know if that was already said or not just my opinion..
Great idea tho

I remember reading this thread and I found it interesting. A lot of good arguments for all 3 options.

http://www.badbeatspoker.net/forum/h...-invested.html

Let's try to get this list finalized, so we can create a new "Best Of" section. :)

I think just a simple Icon for maybe the real hot treads or have another Icon for the best of BBP Threads. That away each Thread can stay in place. :biglaugh:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by otbdave

I saw we move all the threads to a new forum, lock the thread so noone can reply, and the last post will be a redirect link to where they can reply.

The purpose is so we can give a single URL to show a prospective user the best of the best. This is why I don't think sticky aligns with this goal.

---

I think this is a good plan. I'm not pro/anti-locking, because I'm not sure what the goal of locking it would be.

I think some should probably be stickied though. For example, an excellent strat article probably is better suited stickied in strat.

you could have a stick category for great threads or have a category area for great threads that no one can post a new thread